Jul
11
Dueling Movie Reviews: Dark Water
Filed Under Books and Culture
. . . this is an eerie, relentlessly grim, invasive little movie-a tone poem of despair that seeps into you like the damp. It’s the sort of film that, even in midsummer, makes you wish you’d brought along a couple of heavy sweaters. And maybe an umbrella.
Thomas Hibbs at National Review Online:
“I’m not crazy,” the main character, Dahlia (Jennifer Connelly), exclaims at one point in the new film Dark Water. Given that she is haunted by bad memories of her wicked mother, lives in an apartment with multiple leaks, and has a hard time distinguishing her own daughter from the ghost who lives upstairs, the temptation to judge her insane is pretty strong. She is saved from this judgment by the fact that the film and Connelly’s role in particular are simply fatuous, in the vapid horror-film sense that every decision she makes seems designed for predictably bad results. With only one marginally creepy scene toward the end, this film is a real contender for worst film released this year.
Comments
Leave a Reply













